The Invisible Hand of Bias: Understanding Your Advisor's Perspective

When it comes to financial planning, none of us are perfectly rational actors. Our decisions are colored by personal experiences, beliefs, and yes—biases. As an advice-only financial advisor, I believe in radical transparency, which is why I'm sharing my own biases with you today. Understanding these perspectives can help you make more informed decisions about your financial future and recognize when you might need to question both your advisor's recommendations and your own instincts.

How Biases Affect Our Financial Decisions

Cognitive biases are systematic patterns of deviation from rationality in judgment. In simpler terms, they're mental shortcuts that can lead us astray when making decisions—especially financial ones. These biases can manifest in numerous ways:

• Confirmation bias: Seeking information that confirms existing beliefs while ignoring contradictory evidence
• Recency bias: Giving more weight to recent events than historical patterns
• Loss aversion: Feeling the pain of losses more acutely than the pleasure of equivalent gains
• Overconfidence: Believing we know more or can predict outcomes better than we actually can
• Status quo bias: Preferring things to stay the same, even when change might be beneficial

When these biases affect financial advisors, the consequences can be significant for their clients. An advisor with strong biases toward certain investment strategies might not recommend appropriate alternatives, even when those alternatives would better serve their clients' needs.

My Financial Planning Biases

In the spirit of transparency, here are my own biases across various areas of financial planning. These perspectives inform my advice, for better or worse:

Cash Flow and Debt Management

• Cash Flow Tracking: I prefer simple, high-level tracking rather than detailed budgets
• Renting vs. Buying: I evaluate this on a case-by-case basis with no strong preference
• Credit Card Rewards: I find these to be too much hassle unless you genuinely enjoy optimizing them
• Paying Off Debt vs. Investing: My recommendation depends on interest rates and potential investment returns
• Student Loan Forgiveness: I'm generally in favor of pursuing forgiveness programs

Insurance Planning

• Emergency Funds: I recommend 6 months of expenses
• Term Life Insurance: I believe this is necessary if others depend on you financially
• Permanent Life Insurance: I'm generally against these products
• Health Insurance Subsidies for Wealthy Families: I see these as necessary
• Long-Term Care Funding: I typically recommend self-funding

Investment Planning

• Active vs. Passive Management: I strongly favor passive investing
• Dividend vs. Growth Stocks: I see value in both approaches
• International Diversification: I recommend 20-25% international exposure
• Lump Sum vs. Dollar-Cost Averaging: I see value in dollar-cost averaging in many situations
• Rebalancing Frequency: I suggest once per year or every two years
• ESG Investing: I don't generally recommend this approach
• Digital Assets: I suggest limiting these to less than 5% of investable assets
• Rental Real Estate: I support this for clients willing to handle the responsibilities

Retirement and Tax Planning

• Account Prioritization: I favor retirement accounts before taxable accounts
• Traditional vs. Roth Contributions: My recommendation depends on tax situations
• Distribution Strategies: I generally recommend drawing from taxable accounts first, then tax-deferred, then tax-free
• Social Security Assumptions: I advise against making assumptions if retirement is more than a decade away
• Inflation Assumptions: I use 3% in planning
• Annuities: I generally avoid recommending these due to high fees
• Pension vs. Lump Sum: My recommendation varies based on individual circumstances

Family and Estate Planning

• Family Giving: I evaluate this based on individual situations
• Education Funding: I recommend starting small and early
• Charitable Giving: I'm generally in favor of charitable contributions
• Revocable Trusts: I typically recommend these

Recognizing and Managing Biases

For Clients: How to Identify Your Own Biases

1. Question your comfort zones: If certain financial strategies make you uncomfortable, ask yourself why. Is it rational concern or emotional reaction?
   
2. Notice your reactions: Pay attention to strong emotional responses to financial advice—they often signal underlying biases.
   
3. Diversify your information sources: Read perspectives that challenge your existing views about money and investing.
   
4. Automate where possible: Setting up automatic savings and investment contributions can help bypass psychological barriers.
   
5. Track your decisions: Keep a financial journal noting why you made specific choices and revisit it periodically to identify patterns.
   

How to Evaluate Your Advisor's Biases

1. Ask direct questions: "What are your personal investing preferences?" or "What financial products do you typically avoid recommending?"
   
2. Look for nuance: Be wary of advisors who present absolute certainties in areas where reasonable professionals disagree.
   
3. Consider their business model: Fee-only advisors have different incentives than those who earn commissions on product sales.
   
4. Request explanations: A good advisor should be able to explain both sides of a financial decision, even when they have a clear recommendation.
   
5. Seek second opinions: For major financial decisions, consulting another professional can provide valuable perspective.
   

Conclusion

We all have biases—the difference lies in whether we recognize and account for them in our decision-making. By openly acknowledging my own biases as your financial advisor, I hope to foster a more transparent relationship where we can work together to ensure your financial plan truly reflects your goals and circumstances, not just my preferences.

Remember, the ideal financial plan isn't one that perfectly aligns with conventional wisdom or even your advisor's recommendations—it's one that works for your unique situation, addresses your specific concerns, and helps you sleep well at night while building toward your goals.

‍

What biases might be influencing your financial decisions?